- What is XRP Ledger 32,570?
- Bitcoin’s incidents
A long-standing debate over the decentralization of the XRP Ledger (XRPL) reignited late Sunday night with a dispute between prominent Bitcoin advocate Bram Kanstein and Ripple CTO David Schwartz.
Kanstein has recalled that the ledger’s history does not begin at “Ledger 1,” but rather at “Ledger 32,570.” He views this as proof that XRP is, and has always been, a centralized project.
Schwartz, however, has argued that handling of the XRP genesis “glitch” was actually an example of decentralized inaction. Moreover, the architect behind the XRPL has compared this with two famous Bitcoin incidents that he believes displayed way more centralization
HOT Stories
Ripple’s CTO Emeritus Defends XRP Genesis Against Centralization Claims
Crypto Market Review: Shiba Inu (SHIB) out of Hell, Moment Ethereum (ETH) Investors Have Waited For, Dogecoin (DOGE) Zero Added
“Bitcoin had at least two incidents that showed way more centralization than this incident did, especially since the decision in this incident was *not* to make any coordinated changes and just live with it,” he said.
What is XRP Ledger 32,570?
When the XRP Ledger was launched in June 2012, a bug in the early server software caused the headers for the first week of ledgers to be improperly saved. As a result, Ledgers 1 through 32,569 were permanently lost.
The state of the ledger was preserved and carried forward, but the history for that first week vanished.
Ledger 32,570 became the effective “Genesis” point for all public history servers.
Bitcoin’s incidents
In his retort, Schwartz claimed that Bitcoin had “at least two incidents that showed way more centralization,” referring to moments where Bitcoin’s stakeholders actively intervened to fix critical bugs.
Schwartz has confirmed that he was specifically referring to the value overflow bug.
“But I think you could make a good argument that it does. The biggest one I was thinking of was the coordinated 2010 rollback,” he said.
This is the most critical bug in Bitcoin’s history, often cited by critics to prove that Bitcoin’s immutability relies on human intervention.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Crypto investment inflows rebound as XRP tops weekly gains of $224M
Cryptocurrency investment products saw $224 million in inflows last week, driven primarily by XRP and Bitcoin, despite geopolitical uncertainties. Year-to-date, total inflows reached $1.2 billion, with Ether products experiencing significant outflows.
Cointelegraph49m ago
XRP Whales Accumulate as Ripple Executives Head to Key XRPL Event in Japan
XRP has gained 5% from a support level of $1.28 due to increased whale accumulation, with large holders now buying over 11 million XRP daily. Ripple executives are attending a significant XRPL event in Japan, though broader market sentiment remains cautious amid geopolitical tensions.
CryptoNewsFlash2h ago
XRP is under enormous bearish pressure, with $3.0 billion in liquidations imminent—can a breakout by bulls trigger a massive surge?
XRP’s recent price fluctuations are in the $1.339 to $1.35 range, boosted by the U.S.-Iran ceasefire talks. It rose about 3% in a single day. The key resistance zone is $1.34 to $1.355; analysts say that only by breaking through this area can investors focus on higher targets. Downside support sits at $1.31 to $1.32, and if it breaks below, it could return to the consolidation range. The market is waiting for U.S. economic data, so the near-term dynamics are worth watching.
GateNews3h ago
Africa’s cryptocurrency adoption skyrockets by 52%, with regulation and mobile payments accelerating the rapid spread of digital assets
Gate News updates: Africa’s cryptocurrency market is seeing rapid growth. According to Ripple’s latest report, the total on-chain transaction value in the region grew 52% year over year, a trend closely tied to more and more countries putting clear cryptocurrency regulatory rules in place. Countries such as South Africa, Nigeria, Kenya, and Mauritius are gradually bringing digital assets under financial supervision, giving businesses and users greater confidence and thereby boosting cryptocurrency adoption rates.
GateNews3h ago
XRP Critical Three Weeks: U.S. Senate Legislative Progress Could Decide Whether to Break Above $1.60 or Fall Below $1.20
As the XRP price enters a key policy window, the progress of the U.S. Senate's “CLARITY Act” over the next three weeks will affect its 2026 outlook. XRP is currently trading at about $1.34; if the bill passes smoothly, it could bring in $4.0 billion to $8.0 billion in capital inflows, driving the price higher. Otherwise, it will depend on the broader macro environment and could fall to below $1.20. Policy progress is the dominant factor right now, and April will become a crucial turning point.
GateNews6h ago
