February 25 News: The debate over whether XRP Ledger (XRPL) is a centralized blockchain has quickly heated up in the crypto community. Justin Bons, founder and CIO of Cyber Capital, publicly questioned the decentralization of XRPL, arguing that its reliance on the Unique Node List (UNL) mechanism essentially makes it a “permissioned blockchain,” deviating from the true permissionless crypto network concept.
Justin Bons pointed out that XRPL validators typically refer to recommended node lists published by a central authority. Deviating from this list could lead to network forks, creating potential governance centralization risks. He also categorized XRPL alongside networks like Stellar, Hedera, and Algorand as “permissioned architectures,” emphasizing that blockchains not based on PoW or PoS consensus may be closer to an authority-based proof model (PoA), making full trust minimization difficult.
In response, Ripple’s Chief Technology Officer David Schwartz issued a positive statement, denying that Ripple has absolute control over the XRP Ledger. He explained that XRPL was designed to prevent any single entity from dominating the network, with each node independently choosing which validators to trust, rather than relying solely on official recommendations. Even if validators act dishonestly, nodes can adjust their UNL to maintain consensus security.
David Schwartz further stated that validators cannot force honest nodes to accept double-spend transactions or implement censorship. XRPL confirms transactions through consensus rounds approximately every five seconds, mechanismically reducing risks of censorship and double spending. He acknowledged that, in theory, if most validators colluded, it could impact network operation, but this is a typical majority attack issue, not a structural power Ripple controls alone.
This controversy also raises a core industry question: how should blockchain decentralization standards be defined? Some analysts believe that XRPL’s performance advantages and fast settlement capabilities stem from its unique consensus mechanism, rather than traditional PoW models. Meanwhile, as regulatory environments tighten and institutional attention increases, discussions around the security, decentralization, and governance transparency of permissioned blockchains are expected to intensify, becoming a key factor influencing the long-term narrative of the XRP ecosystem.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Ripple CTO Pushes Back on Claims About XRP Funding Model
David Schwartz defends Ripple's XRP sales against criticism, arguing they provide liquidity and benefit long-term investors. The debate highlights concerns over corporate growth versus retail holder interests, revealing divisions within the XRP community on transparency and market impact.
Coinfomania32m ago
Ripple Set to Buy Back $750M in Shares Despite XRP Price Decline
Ripple plans to buy back up to $750 million in shares from investors and employees by the end of next month, insiders have revealed.
The buybacks would value the company at $50 billion, and come six months after a similar plan to buy back $1 billion in shares from employees failed.
Ripple
CryptoNewsFlash1h ago
XRP Price Breaks Through Key Resistance Level to $1.48, Trading Volume Surges Over 250%
On March 16, XRP price broke through the consolidation zone, rising rapidly from approximately $1.41 to $1.4798, with trading volume increasing over 250%. The current price is stabilizing above $1.4550, and technical analysis shows the next resistance level at $1.48 to $1.50. On-chain activity is also growing, indicating improved market sentiment and increased activity. Key support levels are at $1.43 to $1.44.
GateNews1h ago
XRP Trading Volumes Fall 58% in 24 Hours, Despite Which the Altcoin Price Continues to Rise
XRP trading volumes fall 58% in 24 hours.
Despite this, the altcoin price continues to rise at a steady pace.
This bodes well for the likelihood of a possible XRP pump.
The previous few days have led to what looks to be a steady recovery phase for the crypto market. Presently, the price
CryptoNewsLand2h ago
A Certain CEX's 24-Hour Trading Volume Reaches $1.369 Billion, XRP, BTC, ETH Rank in Top Three
According to CoinGecko data, on March 16, a certain CEX's trading volume reached $1.369 billion, up 72.28% from the previous day. The top five tokens by trading volume are XRP, BTC, ETH, TRUMP, and DKA.
GateNews2h ago
Former Ripple CTO confirms that destroying escrowed XRP does not drive the price, with Ripple outperforming XLM in the market.
Ripple's Chief Technology Officer David Schwartz points out that burning escrowed XRP tokens would not significantly boost the price, and provides historical data of XLM burns as evidence. He emphasizes that market prices depend more on supply and demand dynamics and investor confidence, rather than mere token burning. This perspective may influence XRP community expectations, prompting attention to actual market demand.
GateNews2h ago
