How Many Savings Accounts Should You Actually Have? A Banker's Take

You’ve probably wondered if spreading your money across multiple savings accounts helps you earn more. With high-yield savings accounts now offering competitive APYs that were hard to find years ago, and sign-ups being as simple as downloading an app, the temptation to open several accounts is real. But here’s what a 15-year banking veteran told us: for most people, one is genuinely enough.

The Case for Going Solo

Nick Craven, senior vice president at TAB Bank, is straightforward about this: “The best advice for most people is to have just one savings account.” Why? Because more accounts don’t multiply your money faster or improve compounding. What actually matters is finding the single highest yield available and consolidating your deposits there.

Multiple accounts create unnecessary friction. You’re managing more logins, tracking more statements, and honestly—making more room for mistakes and fees. Security risk also increases with each account you maintain. But here’s the kicker: if you spread too thin, you might miss tiered-yield thresholds. Take CIT Platinum Savings as an example—it pays one of the best rates around, but only on deposits of $5,000 or more. Drop below that minimum, and your rate plummets to 0.25%.

Simplifying your financial life matters here. “When you have just one savings account, it’s easier to see where you stand in relation to your overall goals,” says Craven. That clarity beats complexity every time.

Buckets Beat Multiple Accounts

Maybe you’ve heard the advice to open separate accounts for different goals—one for emergencies, one for a vacation, one for a house down payment. It sounds organized, but it’s outdated thinking.

Most banks now let you create goal-themed buckets within a single account. You get the same benefit—isolating goals and setting automatic contributions—without the headache. You can track progress, make withdrawals from one bucket without touching others, and maintain one login instead of six.

Picking the Right Account

When you’re choosing your single, consolidated savings account, focus on what matters most: how hard your money works. High-yield savings accounts are where it’s at in today’s environment. Several institutions currently pay 4% APY or higher—over 10 times the national average.

Read the fine print carefully. Watch out for teaser rates that look attractive short-term but won’t last. Avoid accounts eroding your principal through hidden fees. And critically, find a bank that doesn’t penalize frequent transactions. (The good news: federal regulations eliminated the six-transaction cap back in April 2020, though some older banks haven’t caught up.)

When Multiple Accounts Actually Make Sense

That said, no one rule fits everybody. A handful of situations warrant keeping more than one account:

• You’re a high-net-worth saver. If your deposits exceed the FDIC coverage limit of $250,000, you’ll need multiple accounts to stay protected. FDIC insures up to $250,000 per depositor per institution.

• You want overdraft backup. Some people link a separate savings account solely to their checking for overdraft protection.

• You’d lose benefits by consolidating. Occasionally, closing an account means losing a higher rate or special perks reserved for customers with multiple profiles.

• You have joint and independent accounts. Maybe you share a joint account with a spouse but also want independent holdings.

• There’s a sign-up bonus worth it. Sometimes the promotional incentive actually justifies opening a second account, though this is rare.

The Bottom Line

“I advocate for maintaining a singular savings account with a routine schedule of regular deposits,” is Craven’s final word. Right now, while rates remain elevated, concentrating your money in the best high-yield savings account available—rather than scattering it—will genuinely maximize your returns. Pick one account that delivers, set up automatic monthly contributions, and let it work for you. That’s how most people should think about how many savings accounts they really need.