Vitalik Buterin warns about the limitations of the prediction market

Co-founder of Ethereum, Vitalik Buterin, has spoken out about the increasingly heated debate surrounding the prediction market, emphasizing that the lack of profit-generating mechanisms makes these platforms less attractive to cautious traders.

In a post on Farcaster, Buterin talked about the opportunity cost when arguing that the lack of yield forces participants to give up guaranteed profits elsewhere, such as the 4% annual yield from USD, just to participate in this market. He suggested that when the yield gap issue is addressed, "many use cases for hedging risks will emerge," thereby boosting liquidity and acceptance.

Controversy over the structure of the prediction market

Buterin's comments come amid online discussions about the risks and potential of platforms like Polymarket and Kalshi exploding, following a post by former quantitative trader Agustin Lebron. He argues that the prediction market has structural flaws and could cause social instability by creating a feedback loop between bets and actual outcomes.

Lebron emphasized that these markets lack diversity among hedgers, speculators, and institutional investors — factors that are fundamental to traditional financial markets. Without hedgers to transfer risk, the prediction market can easily become a game between seasoned traders and retail investors, leading to unsustainable liquidity.

Supportive Critique

LeBron's viewpoint has received feedback from anonymous trader @TomJrSr, who revealed having financial interests in the industry. In a lengthy response, he argues that LeBron underestimates the long-term potential of the prediction market in providing valuable hedging tools for businesses and individuals affected by real-world fluctuations.

He wrote:

"Airlines face storms, utility companies are affected by unpredictable weather, and energy businesses are impacted by OPEC quotas."

According to him, the prediction market can provide a cheaper and more direct way to hedge risks compared to current financial instruments.

With Buterin pointing out the issue of lack of yield and two distinctly opposing viewpoints, the prediction market is at a crossroads: to become a niche speculative game or a legitimate tool for risk management and price discovery.

Vương Tiễn