Conagra Stock (CAG) Tops S&P 500 Yield and Looks Like a Buy

Conagra Brands CAG +1.62% ▲ is currently the highest-yielding stock in the S&P 500 (SPX), making it a compelling buy for investors seeking a high-payout anchor amid an increasingly volatile market. Boasting a roughly 8.5% dividend yield, this consumer staples giant offers a level of defensive stability that “exciting” tech stocks simply cannot match in today’s geopolitical and AI-driven uncertainties.

Claim 70% Off TipRanks Premium

• Unlock hedge fund-level data and powerful investing tools for smarter, sharper decisions

• Stay ahead of the market with the latest news and analysis and maximize your portfolio’s potential

While a packaged-foods business might seem boring on the surface, Conagra’s strategic $220 million investment in its Arkansas poultry infrastructure proves the company is aggressively innovating to protect its cash flow. In a shaky market, Conagra turns “waiting” into a high-paying strategy for investors. For those looking to get paid handsomely to wait for a sector recovery, there is nothing “boring” about the S&P 500’s new yield king. I remain bullish about CAG.

**King of the Dividend Hill **

Conagra outperforms every other S&P 500 company in stock payout. It remains ahead of fellow food purveyor The Campbell’s Company CPB +1.64% ▲ and healthcare real estate investment trust (REIT) Healthpeak Properties DOC +2.73% ▲ , which yield 7.2% and 6.5% respectively, by a comfortable margin. Furthermore, shares of Conagra offer roughly double the yield of 10-year Treasuries, which currently yield 4.3%. Ultimately, this over-8.5% yield stands out in an environment where the average yield on the S&P 500 is just about 1.3%.

Conagra also offers strong dividend longevity. The stock has paid dividends to its shareholders every quarter since 1976. With a dividend payout ratio of 73%, there likely isn’t much room for dividend growth in the near future. While there doesn’t seem to be an immediate risk of a dividend cut, investors should watch out in case the stock’s earnings decline.

Analysts project Conagra’s earnings per share (EPS) to increase from $1.72 in Fiscal 2026 to $1.80 in 2027, reflecting modest growth that can support its annual dividend without strain. This isn’t spectacular earnings growth, but it is growth nevertheless. It leads me to believe that Conagra isn’t just a “yield trap”—a high-yield stock attracting investors despite likely dividend cuts. Unlike chemical maker LyondellBasell LYB +3.55% ▲ , the previous highest-yielding company in the S&P 500 that recently cut its dividend by nearly half, Conagra’s payout appears better supported.

**Conagra Products Build a Case  **

I like Conagra’s positioning for the uncertain economic climate we are currently navigating. The offerings are staples rather than luxuries, and no matter what happens with AI disruption or the broader economy, consumers will continue to purchase basic foodstuffs, making Conagra a resilient investment well-suited for the volatile environment we find ourselves in.

Of late, we see food companies grappling with the challenges posed by GLP-1s and shifting consumer tastes towards healthier choices. Even in this scenario, Conagra seems fairly well-positioned to navigate these shifts. While it may not be the healthiest food company in the world, with brands like Slim Jim and Duncan Hines on its roster, its portfolio also includes healthier options such as Birds Eye vegetables, BOOMCHICKAPOP popcorn, Healthy Choice frozen meals, Udi’s Gluten Free products, and David sunflower seeds.

**Valuation Looks Attractive  **

Not only does Conagra offer an outsized dividend yield, but the stock also trades at a single-digit price-to-earnings multiple of just 9.5x 2026 earnings estimates. With earnings projected to rise to $1.80 per share in Fiscal 2027, the valuation looks even more attractive on a forward basis, trading at roughly 9.1x 2027 earnings estimates.

This stands in sharp contrast to the broader market, where the S&P 500 trades for about 21x forward earnings estimates, making the average S&P 500 stock roughly twice as expensive as Conagra.

I believe the stock’s high yield and low valuation should support the share price going forward, with much of the downside already reflected in the current sentiment. At the same time, any improvement in earnings or sentiment could drive meaningful upside through multiple expansion.

Is CAG Stock a Buy, According to Analysts?

Turning to Wall Street, CAG earns a Hold consensus rating based on one Buy, nine Hold, and two Sell ratings assigned in the past three months. The average stock price target of $18.73 implies 16.8% upside potential from current levels.

**Investor Takeaway **

This isn’t the most glamorous stock out there, but Conagra Brands looks well-suited to the current market as investors flee from high-risk, high-reward growth stocks and seek more defensive names. There’s no risk of AI disruption here, and Conagra’s tried-and-true business model of selling basic foodstuffs should mitigate the effects of economic uncertainty. In addition to this resilient business model, Conagra appeals to investors seeking to mitigate the risks inherent to today’s market with its S&P 500’s best 8.5% dividend yield and its low valuation, both of which should provide a backstop for the share price going forward.

Disclaimer & DisclosureReport an Issue